One of the five works published within the last thirty years which in the opinion of representative scholars and critics have contributed most to the understanding of literature.--
Contemporary Literary ScholarshipAbrams has written a remarkable book on the history of criticism, the most distinguished contribution of American scholarship in that field since the work of J.E. Spingarn.--
Comparative LiteratureThe book is so rich in thought that it is invaluable for students of the romantic movement and indeed of the whole theory of criticism. I regard it as one of the most distinguished achievements of American literary scholarship of our day.--
Modern PhilologyWith this book, M.H. Abrams has given us a remarkable study, admirably conceived and executed, a book of quite exceptional and no doubt lasting significance for a number of fields--for the history of ideas and comparative literature as well as for English literary history, criticism, and aesthetics.--
Modern Language JournalThe past forty years have seen many attempts at ordering our ideas about literature;
The Mirror and the Lamp stands out among them as a unique combination of rich historical scholarship and hard-won clarity of thought.--
The Times Literary Supplement (London)